[Editor’s note: the post that follows is the first of a series of posts from David on a recent trip to Seattle, and the planning he had to undertake to utilize the Direct Current Fast Charging (DCFC) network south of the border. He is also located in BC, in New Westminster, owns a 2013 Leaf SL, and has an EV Family!]
Hello from the New West EV Family! Ha! Sorry Andrew- I’m copying your blog title out of a complete lack of originality on my own part. This is my first blog/guest blog post ever, on any blog. I have contemplated blogging for many years. Nissan Leaf ownership has pushed me over the edge and Andrew has volunteered to humour me by hosting these guest posts on his blog! Please be gentle as my thoughts unwind on you. Please let me know how I can improve too and perhaps soon I’ll start my own blog.The New West EV Family consists of me (David), my wife and my 5 y/o son. After the birth of our son, we decided we needed (wanted) two vehicles with both parents working full time. Our primary vehicle for 9 years has been a 2005 VW Passat Wagon TDI. The TDI has and continues to be a tremendous car because it gets very good fuel economy, it has been amazingly versatile, has better luggage carrying capacity than most SUVs, it has generous passenger space, it can tow generous trailers and it has been reliable to us (despite a few glitches). (Note this post was penned before #dieselgate and our 2005 TDI is not included in #dieselgate – it certainly emits much more NOx!)
Here are some photos paying homage to our tremendous TDI. After this we will focus on Electric Vehicles!
Click on any image to see a full-size gallery.
When my wife returned to work after mat leave we purchased a colleague’s 1995 Chevy Cavalier for $1,200. It was in great shape for being nearly 20 years old and had low km’s. Unfortunately we had to replace a head gasket a year later for about $1,700. We drove it for 3 years, putting about 14,000 km on it per year. I got really fed up with the 20 year old vehicle, the poor passenger and luggage space, and poor fuel economy. And boy, when you have a child, you really notice the lack of remote door locking!
In January 2014 I had begun in earnest to research the Nissan Leaf. Overall I dislike the Nissan brand as a whole but I was very intrigued by the Leaf. Later that year in April the BC government terminated the Clean Energy Vehicle (CEV) rebate program and I shelved my interest for some time. In 2015 EVs were on the roll and the BC gov’t re-introduced the CEV incentives, along with the privately run Scrap-It program in the spring. We got interested again and I started scoping out the used market on Craigslist for several months.
In April 2015 we purchased a used 2013 Leaf SL with ~32,000 km on the clock. Including dealer negotiation and less the $3,250 Scrap-It rebate from the 1995 Chevy we paid about $21,000 for the Leaf before taxes and fees (the provincial CEV grant is only for new vehicles). We have loved every minute of the drive.
I expected the Leaf to cost us about $15 a month in electricity to drive or about $130 a year, displacing around $1,200-1,400 in gas costs per year for the Chevy. So far this assumption is looking to be correct.
We chose the Leaf because a battery electric vehicle (BEV) suited our lifestyle, which now revolves around many short trips in town such as daycare, pre-school, kindergarten, swimming at the community center, shopping, short commutes to work etc. The BEV made so much sense for this scenario of multiple short trips. My wife’s total commute, including kid drop offs, is about 25 km return. We haven’t even needed an L2 EVSE at home, though I am aware of the issues of relying on L1 charging. [Editor’s note: the main concern is the safety of the outlet you plug into since the car pulls 12A using the L1 trickle charger, which is right at the threshold of the commonly used safety factor of 80% of a circuit’s rating, and a typical home circuit is 15A.] We use the Leaf for all around-town trips now and the TDI is only used to take me to work, out of town family trips, or trailer duty.
Speaking of out of town trips, we (ok, more me than my wife) wanted to see what extended range travel in the Leaf was like. The goal was to visit Seattle for a couple days with the target destination of the Woodland Park Zoo. With this goal in mind I began assessing the charge networks and routing on plugshare.com and began what became an arduous process of becoming a member at a myriad of charging networks.
To successfully and quickly make it to the Seattle area DCFC charging is required and the DCFC infrastructure south of the border is pretty decent but also fragmented. I would need to ensure I could use the AeroVironment (AV) DCFC chargers (one of the network providers of the West Coast Electric Highway) and I would need to be prepared with back up plans. Nearly all L2 and DCFC charging south of the border is pay per use and nearly all require a membership card and/or RFID fob. Most charging stations will not just take credit cards like the L2 ChargePoints around Metro Vancouver. Preparation is required!
To make matters worse for Canadians traveling south of the border, we lose our easy cell phone connectivity; roaming charges have been steep in the past, and while slightly more reasonable now, they are still something to avoid for short trips. Can you imagine traveling somewhere unknown without instant access to PlugShare? What if your RFID fob does not work and you are on hold for 10 minutes at $1.50 a minute? There goes your feel good trip.
Now I know EV ownership isn’t just about being frugal, but it sure is a nice side effect. If I have to rely on cellphone data and voice for all charging events I may as well just take the TDI and forget about the Leaf (the TDI is approx. 8.6 cents per km fuel over my 9 year average). So we need charge network memberships and access cards, and they have to be activated and working before our departure. The goal is not to have to use cellular data/voice roaming.
AeroVironment – I have to have access to this network with two DCFC charges to get you down to the Seattle area. As a Canadian, with a Canadian address and a Canadian-billed credit card, sometimes purchasing things in the US is difficult. It went smoothly with AV; their website allowed my Canadian address, however the catch was the RFID fob cost $15 and the flat rate monthly fee is $20. I wanted the fob NOW to ensure I could make the decision to travel at any time (we had not set a schedule and were intending to travel with another family). With just a phone call to AV you can activate or suspend the monthly fee for your account. But at the initial purchase you have to activate your account AND pay the 1st month. I begged, pleaded, tried to make deals with them, called many times, talked to different customer service reps, e-mailed public relations, but nothing I did changed their mind. I could not simply buy an active RFID fob with an inactive monthly account. I had to settle for ordering the fob just before our planned departure and hope the fob made it to Canada in time. Either that or we take the TDI. It turned out well. I ordered the fob on August 20th, expecting to travel September 11th, and the fob arrived about 10 days after ordering. I logged in and confirmed it was active. Here’s hoping it works. Total cost $15 + $20 USD 1st month unlimited charging. I expect to charge at AV a minimum of 4 times (twice south and twice north), which would be $7.50 each if you are a non-member, and it would be $30 + roaming fees on your phone to use Pay-by-PlugShare, so membership sounds ok to me.
NRG – EVGO – Relatively new to the Seattle Market, EVGO opened up a few DCFC stations near areas we like to stop such as Seattle Premium Outlet and Northgate mall. As of this writing the Northgate location is more than 3 months late opening. However, I wanted the EVGO membership to open more options for DCFC charging for just-in-case scenarios. EVGO was the hardest account for a Canadian to subscribe to. I also begged and pleaded with them. The main problem is their website does not allow entry of non-USA addresses. On the phone they were quite happy to mail me a membership card if they could link it to a US credit card. They told me over and over a Canadian Credit card would NOT work, which I highly doubted. This just seemed wrong. I investigated many workarounds including pre-paid credit cards. I learnt that most prepaid credit card had nasty dormancy fees and the more beneficial cards were next to impossible to get via mail order. I then investigated a service that provides a virtual pre-paid credit card.
This sounded interesting, but in the end just a little too sketchy. I opted for the AMERIFRIEND. I don’t have many acquaintances in the US I could call in for this favour, but my wife has a cousin living in the Pheonix area and they were willing to help. I was able to successfully obtain my EVGO card using my name and Canadian credit card with their USA mailing address. The card arrived at their home and our AmeriCousin-in-law mailed it to me. The other method we could have used would have been to obtain this card using one of the cross border post office services commonly in operation around the border towns. I didn’t want to make the trek to the USA just for a card and didn’t want the unknown quantity of picking up the membership card (potentially inactivated) on the way south during the trip. I wanted everything to be in order before we left. Membership was $10 USD and I opted for the zero monthly fee, pay as you go plan. UPDATE: recently I noticed on the Canadian Leaf Facebook group that someone has been able to get their EVGO card directly mailed to Canada so perhaps the policies have changed.
ChargePoint – a number of good DCFC and L2 chargers in the Seattle area use ChargePoint, including DCFC’s at Nissan dealerships. Luckily ChargePoint operates in Canada too, and it is very easy to get your membership card with one caveat: you must prepay a balance onto your ChargePoint card and the minimum is $25. I got my card a few months ago. It will be necessary for the trip. Note: they don’t bill the pre-paid $25 until your first billable charge.
Greenlots – also operates in Canada and it is easy to obtain your fob for around $10. Then you have to link a credit card to it in your online account. There are 1 or 2 Greenlots DCFC’s in Seattle that are on our route. Nice to have.
SEMAcharge – A handful of locations in Seattle and Vancovuer use SEMAcharge. I won’t have the card for my Seattle trip, but I did just register and apparently they are sending me a card to my Canadian address at no cost to me (yes it has arrived at no cost in about 7 days). I will have to link to a CC for future paid use. You can also use a smartphone to activate charging or pay via PlugShare with Sema, however the hope is not to use the cell phone on this trip.
GE Wattstation – A minority of locations both in Seattle and Vancouver use GE Wattstation. Most PlugShare reviews are highly critical of the GE Wattstation pay process. The only way to obtain a GE Wattstation RFID card is from Amazon.com – no shipping to Canada! You can activate by a smartphone if you need but you’ll have to switch on data roaming if you are out of country! As I am writing this a new e-mail came to me from GE. They told me Amazon.com is the only method to purchase a card. I replied I am in Canada and cannot receive goods from Amazon.com and they have offered to send me a card at no charge! Yay! I’ll keep you posted. (As of October 15, about 30 days later, this card has not arrived.)
Blink – The network that Seattle area residents seem to love to hate – based only on my PlugShare observations. I think this is mainly because of lack of maintenance and Blink DCFC’s often go un-repaired for weeks or months [Editor’s Note: the running joke on InsideEVs.com is that the network is aptly named, since they often go on the blink!] Guests can charge at Blink DCFC stations, but you are required to generate a guest code by mobile app (roaming), by voice call (roaming), or in advance on your computer. Membership appears to be free, but I elected to sign up for a guest code. Member charging rates are $0.39/kWh and the guest rate is $0.49/kWh in the Washington State market area. The problem is the number of Blink stations in the Seattle area with un-repaired vandalism (or other) includes PlugShare photos of broken LCD screens on the charger. I suspect this would present a problem for entering the guest code making the smartphone app the required method (roaming fees) for initiating a charge.
VERnetwork – Operating out of Quebec there are a few VERnetwork AddEnergie chargers around Vancouver on our local routes and I wanted to be able to use them sans smartphone app so I bought the card for $10. PS, don’t drill a hole in the card. I did this to put it on a key-ring and learnt this lesson the hard way. I even used a super bright LED flash light to avoid drilling areas of the card that looked to be RFID active.
There you have it, the summary of EV charging network cards that I chose to obtain for our expedition south of Vancouver. Stay tuned for the trip reports.
David, New West EV Family!